Home / Essential Ethics / November 16, 2026

Essential Ethics

November 16, 2026

Latest Developments:

Michigan Utility Companies Challenge Ban on their Political Contributions

Two days after more than 80% of Michigan voters approved a campaign finance act that bans investor-owned utilities and other state-regulated contractors from making political contributions in the state, DTE Energy and Consumers Energy filed a federal lawsuit to block the ban’s implementation. DTE, Consumers Sue to Block Money Out of Politics Measure The lawsuit contends the ban violates the 1st and 14th Amendments. The ban prevents the companies from contributing directly to state elected officials or candidates, covering regulated electric and gas utilities and contractors with over $250,000 a year in government contracts, and also reaches their PACs, principals, board members, key executives, lobbyists and family members.

Lawsuit Seeks to Block Montana’s Successful Measure Banning Corporate Contributions

As previously reported in Essential Ethics, Montana voters pursued – and on November 3rd approved – a measure that redefines the powers of “artificial persons” so they cannot donate to candidates, political parties, or state or local ballot issues. Initiative 194. But in Montana, unlike Michigan, challengers didn’t wait: groups including the Montana Republican State Central Committee filed a federal lawsuit to challenge the law’s constitutionality on Election Day, before the race was officially called. Montana Free Press – Legal Challenge to Montana Plan Initiative The lawsuit alleges the initiative violates First Amendment rights to freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom of the press.

California Voters Approve Campaign and Governance Reforms

Voters approved numerous measures changing campaign regulations, creating ethics commissions, and amending ballot measure laws and forms of governance. Unofficial results show the following measures will pass, with Essential Ethics providing more detail on some in future editions:

  • In Los Angeles County, Measure E adopts laws governing the County’s new Ethics Commission.
  • In the City of Los Angeles, Measure EE amends city ethics laws, increases signature requirements for referenda from 10% to 15%, and increases penalties for campaign finance violations.
  • Los Angeles’ Measure SC clarifies campaign finance rules for Board of Education elections.
  • In Irvine, California, Measure D establishes instant-runoff voting.
  • In San Francisco, Proposition D increases signature requirements for initiatives from 2% to 8%, removes the ability of the Mayor or Supervisors to place measures on the ballot, and allows proponents to withdraw measures.
  • In San Diego County, Measure A increases supervisors’ term limits to three terms, gives Supervisors confirmation authority over senior staff, and authorizes creation of an independent Ethics Commission, a budget analyst and a program auditor.

Preliminary Injunction Granted Against Department of Defense Enforcement of Lobbying Ban

A California federal judge ordered the U.S. Department of Defense to stop enforcing a legal code that prohibits the department from contracting with any entity that retains the same lobbyists as companies designated “Chinese military companies.” U.S. District Judge Eumi Lee granted a preliminary injunction motion to enjoin the department from barring Alibaba from employing lobbyists in Washington, finding it met its initial burden to claim the law infringes on its First Amendment rights to speech and to petition the government. Judge halts Defense Department from barring lobbyists | Courthouse News Service

Creating A Universal Standard to Measure Corporate “Impact Investments”

A Wall Street Journal opinion piece considered how companies can measure how their investments improve lives, with metrics such as “Medicaid patients treated or carbon emissions avoided.” The commentary noted that creating a universal standard to measure impact investments “may be among the most consequential things we can do to expand economic opportunity” and attract investment capital. It cited Global Impact Investing Network’s estimate that, in 2024, nearly 4,000 organizations managed $1.57 trillion in impact investments worldwide – promising to deliver “financial returns while improving lives.” How Do Investors Measure ‘Social Impact’? – WSJ

Appellate Court Dismisses Challenge to Georgia Law Allowing Unlimited Fundraising for Officials with Leadership Committees

Safe Affordable Georgia, a PAC chaired by primary election gubernatorial candidate Brad Raffensperger, had challenged the state’s leadership committee statute, which allows select state officeholders to form leadership committees that operate without fundraising limits, giving them an “unfair advantage” over individuals and PACs. The appellate court held the case moot because the candidate lost in the primary. Opinion and 11th Circ. Nixes Challenge To Ga. Campaign Finance Law – Law360

 

Events and Reminders:

The FPPC has moved its meeting on the updated Form 700 to December 3. As reported in the previous issue of Essential Ethics, the California Fair Political Practices Commission planned to consider updated versions of seven forms, including the Form 700 Statement of Economic Interests, at its November 19, 2026 meeting. Updates will include the new 2027-2028 gift limit and changes from AB 1029, which takes effect January 1, 2027. Text AB 1029 California – Chaptered The Commission has now moved that meeting to December 3, 2026. https://www.fppc.ca.gov/

 

In Case You Missed It:

Companies Bracing for “Aggressive Corruption Hunt” of Their Ties to Trump

Some tech, financial, cryptocurrency and industrial companies are “scrambling to get ahead” of Democrats’ potential congressional oversight. Congressional Democrats have expressed interest in probing how companies have worked with the Trump administration – including those who donated to the President’s “pet projects.” The inevitable headlines should not surprise donors who vetted contributions and considered the risks. Politico – Did Your Company Donate to Trump’s Ballroom Project? Call Your Lawyer and also, NY Times – Tech Billionaires Face Tricky Political Waters

Looking Back at the Megadonors Who Spent $2 Billion on the Midterms

But how do they feel about their spending now? Written before the election, The New York Times tracked the money flowing since August, with updated names and figures of the top 20 who “pumped roughly $2 billion into federal races this cycle.” The article added three new Democrats to the list, though it noted there was “a strong Republican and tech-oriented tilt to the biggest spenders.” NY Times – Meet the Megadonors

RNC Files New Lawsuit Over Low Political Ad Rates

Days before the midterms, the Republican National Committee, Republican Party of Texas and several Republican candidates filed another lawsuit challenging the fact that party committees cannot pay the Federal Election Campaign Act’s “lowest charge unit.” The FCC requirement requires broadcasters to set charges for candidates’ campaign ads at the rate they give their most favored commercial advertisers. The lawsuit comes just weeks after the U.S. Supreme Court weighed in on a related case. RNC Files New Suit Over FCC’s Campaign Ad Rates – Law360

Former FEC Commissioners Say President’s Hold Over Super PAC Violates Campaign Finance Laws

In a Washington Post opinion piece, two former Commissioners of the Federal Elections Commission questioned the President’s claim that he can control and direct MAGA Inc.’s spending, calling it a violation of campaign finance laws. Washington Post – Opinion – Trump Campaign Finance Abuses

Hackers Target FEC’s Electronic Filing System, Causing Outage Before the Midterms

One week before the midterms, hackers targeted the Federal Election Commission’s electronic filing system, causing an outage as candidates faced 48-hour reporting deadlines. CNBC reported that the outage blocked “time-sensitive campaign finance disclosures” days before the election. CNBC – Hackers target FEC as campaign money system goes dark before midterms